NY City Council Hearing: The Regulation and Use of the Unallocated Portion of the Radio Spectrum, Also Known as White Spaces on Sep 28 @ 10am

The New York City Council is holding a hearing on “The Regulation and Use of the Unallocated Portion of the Radio Spectrum, Also Known as White Spaces” on Monday, September 28th @ 10am in the Committee Room at City Hall. I will be there presenting on behalf of NYCwireless. We need as many people as we can get to attend and support us.

Here’s a press release from Josh Breitbart and Free Press about the hearing:

Groups Call on NYC to Open Public Airwaves to New Technology

City Council should embrace ‘white spaces’ and bring high-speed Internet to all New Yorkers

NEW YORK — Community media, public interest and immigrant rights advocates are calling on the New York City Council to endorse “white spaces” technology that could boost the economy and drive down the cost of mobile phone calls and Internet access.

White spaces are the unused portions of the public airwaves between television channels. According to a study conducted by Free Press, one-fifth of New York City’s television channels are currently not being used. New technology can use this vacant spectrum to send powerful, high-speed Internet signals — connecting New Yorkers to a fast, open and affordable Internet.

“Opening the white spaces would close the digital divide, and it wouldn’t cost us a dime — or, rather, it would save us a lot more than a dime on what we’re paying now for Internet access and cell phone service,” said Joshua Breitbart, policy director of People’s Production House.

The Federal Communications Commission is currently considering whether to open up the white spaces to the public. Engineers at the FCC, through extensive testing, have shown that low-power, mobile devices can utilize white spaces to connect to the Internet without interfering with TV broadcasts and wireless microphones on adjacent channels.

Lobbyists from the National Association of Broadcasters, cell phone carriers and wireless microphone companies have launched a misinformation campaign to prevent white spaces from being used to provide high-speed broadband access.

“Unfortunately, many key decision-makers simply lack the bandwidth to investigate the benefits of white spaces technology,” said Timothy Karr, campaign director of Free Press. “Instead they hear misinformation from industry lobbyists who come knocking with lies and spin meant to paint this technology as a danger to humanity.”

A draft resolution currently before the City Council, sponsored by Councilmember Gale Brewer and Speaker Christine Quinn, claims white space devices would be “devastating” to Broadway productions. The City Council Committee on Technology in Government is holding a hearing on the resolution on Monday, Sept. 29, 2008, at 10 a.m., in the Committee Room of City Hall. It is a public forum where anyone can testify.

“White spaces could provide an affordable alternative for people like me who use expensive phone cards to call family and friends back home in other countries,” said Abdulai Bah of Nah We Yone, a community group that advocates for African refugees in New York.

Your Comments on the 900 MHz Spectrum Band Needed

I just filed the comments to support the Media Access Project and the New America Foundation in fighting for more unlicensed spectrum in the 900 MHz spectrum band. Please add your support by filing comments in the box called Proceeding enter 06-49.

Your comments can be as simple as “I support the Media Access Project, the New America Foundation and community wireless organizations nationwide in advocating for more unlicensed wireless spectrum.”

Here are the comments that I filed:

As a member of the Board of Directors of NYCwireless, a community wireless organization in New York, and a member of the FCC’s Consumer Advisory Committee, I would like to support the comments filed by the Media Access Project and the New America Foundation with respect to the 900 MHz band. Community wireless organizations and municipal wireless projects greatly need access to more unlicensed spectrum in the 900 MHz band due to interference, especially in large urban areas. These wireless networks are key to improving economic development and political participation as well as providing social and cultural benefits to communities nationwide.

Harold Feld provides the following information:

Date: Wed, 31 May 2006 13:39:03 -0400
From: Harold Feld

I’d like to ask for the support of everyone on this list in trying to defend unlicensed access in the 900 MHz spectrum band, and help push to expand availability.

Back in 1999, the FCC auctioned licenses for the Location and Monitoring Service (LMS). The licenses share the 904.00-928.00 MHz band with unlicensed users, subject to power limitations and a “safe harbor” to protect unlicensed users. These limits make the service fairly worthless, as shown in the auction price ($4.5 million for all licenses combined).

The LMS licensees, rather than actually build the service, have sat on the spectrum and whined at the FCC to give them increased spectrum rights at the expense of the unlicensed users. Sadly, because there are no defenders of unlicensed spectrum at the FCc anymore, the FCC has now put such a proposal out for comment. While paying lip service to the concept of protecting the status quo on 900 MHZ unlicensed, the order makes clear that it will not worry too much if improving life for the licensed services harms the unlicensed users.

Yesterday, MAP and New America Foundation filed comments arguing that if the FCC wants to do something to improve the 900 MHz band, it should focus on improving the ability to use unlicensed spectrum in the band rather than improve life for speculators who picked up bargain-basement licenses and now want to get free benefits from the Commission. You can read the comments here:

http://gullfoss2.fcc.gov/prod/ecfs/retrieve.cgi?native_or_pdf=pdf&id_document=6518357368

I’d like to ask everyone who can to take a minute and file comments with the FCC opposing the proposed rules and supporting our comments. This will only take five minutes and can potentially make a huge difference. Given the current leadership of the FCC, which I would describe as indifferent to unlicensed users, it will require a large number of comments to persuade the FCC that their proposal will have a major impact on people’s lives.

To file, simply click on this link:

http://gullfoss2.fcc.gov/prod/ecfs/upload_v2.cgi

In the box called Proceeding (box 1) enter 06-49.

Fill out the rest of the form. You can either type a brief comment into the window or attach a comment using the template provided.

You do not need to be a lawyer, or even a US citizen.

Harold

NYCwireless Monthly Meeting – Wed. May 25th 7:15 PM

NYCwireless Meetings have something for everybody, whether you’re a novice or a wireless industry technologist. NYCw meetings feature a cutting-edge technology presentation that will expand your knowledge, followed by breakout sessions where beginners can learn the basics. Need a question answered? You’ll probably find the answer at the NYCwireless monthly meeting.

Meeting is free and located at Bway.net, 459 Broadway in Manhattan. Details below.

The May Meeting is on Wed, May 25th at 7:15pm.
Free wireless internet is provided, of course.
Date/Time: Wednesday, May 25th @ 7:15pm

Meeting Cost: Free!

Agenda (times are approximate):
7:15 Intro to NYCw & Announcements
7:30 Presentation: HDTV via wifi!
8:45 Mixing – break-out groups by topic, and informal schmoozing

Presentation: “The history of bringing HDTV to an Access Point” by Brian Walden.
Brian, a longtime NYCwireless member, is an excellent speaker. His presentation will cover:

  • how we went from UHV to HDTV to 802.11g
  • why 802.11g should be able to handle a lot traffic
  • why the new HDTV standard is the future but isn’t backward compatible to RV owners (no HDTV for RVers),
  • and much more.

Following presentation:

  • Hands-on Breakout Sessions – divide into various focus groups: (e.g. Intro to Beginners, Antennas and Access Points, Volunteerism, Soekris Development, Network Security)
  • Other miscellaneous updates.
  • SIG Updates

Meeting Location: Bway.net, 459 Broadway, 2nd Floor.
About 2 blocks north of Canal, near the SW corner of Grand St. On the west side of the street, then up one flight of stairs. Via subway (Canal Street stop): the J,M,N,Q,R,W,Z, and a bit further, but still on Canal is A,C,E,1,6,9.

FCC Rules on 3650mhz band

NYCwireless firmly believe in spectrum reform that allows fully licensed exempt operation. We have tremendous respect for Harold’s position on this issue and agree with his conclusion that we need to be open to different approaches for different users. The Wireless ISP community was pushing hard to get access to this band for high powered rural usage and it appears what they got was a “license-lite” solution.